Katrina break down Essay - 771 Words

Which of the three perspectives do you find most persuasive? Least persuasive? Setting aside the philosophical and legal issues this case raises, what are the management or efficiency arguments for and against a more centralized response to large national disasters like Hurricane Katrina? Why would we not want to have a federal fire department? If the federal government tells the states and cities they will receive no assistance in the event of a disaster, what do you think will happen? personal responsibility and neighborly concern is a superior substitute for government intervention.† Clearly, Landy conceptualizes federalism as being composed of four dimensions: three levels of government and the civic†¦show more content†¦If indeed a major, or perhaps even the major, cause of death from Katrina was a failure to obey a mandatory evacuation order, this puts the whole Katrina problem in a different light. It shifts the blame from errors made by the various levels of government to the actions of the populace itself. Case Questions 1. Which of the three perspectives do you find most persuasive? Least persuasive? Support your answer. 2. Much of the debate over the response to Hurricane Katrina centers on the question of the division of responsibility among different levels of government—local, state, and federal. If the federal government played a more aggressive role—say, taking command of all response All rights reserved. No distribution allowed without express authorization 9781111632366, Managing the Public Sector, Grover Starling -  © Cengage Learning. 156 Part One POLITICAL MANAGEMENT efforts and placing them in the hands of the regular army—would that violate tenets of federalism, specific provisions of the Constitution, and specific statutes (such as the Posse Comitatus Act of 1878, which limits military participation in law enforcement)? What other legal options are there besides giving the federal government a more powerful role? 3. Setting aside the philosophical and legal issues this case raises,Show MoreRelatedAnalysis Of The Book The Night By F. Scott Fitzgerald1503 Words   |  7 PagesGod, you do not know how happy I am to go home! Oh I should probably introduce myself. Hello I am Katrina Potter. Most call me Kat unless they want to be hexed. Potter you may ask? Sadly I am James’ little sister and by little I mean five minutes and thirty-seven seconds younger. Yes we are twins. By coming home I mean I am moving back to England from Ilvermorny School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, located in America. Why did I go there you may ask? Mum and Dad thought it was best the James and I tookRead MoreCreative Writing : My Life966 Words   |  4 PagesI was scared, tired, and hungry. Quickly, I took inventory of what was around the abandoned house to at least give me a break from my own thoughts. What I counted up was two cans of green beans, some weird New Orleans Okra stew, three bottles of water, and a green wool blanket. I laid out the items, and made a bed to sleep on. My eyes were on the verge of tears, but I laid down and tried to relax in this horrible situation. My eyes opened by sun cracked windows, and I looked around to see the damageRead MoreClassical Principles or Argument Essay1169 Words   |  5 Pagesthis particular essay. Everyone remembers Hurricane Katrina, was it really Katrina that caused all the damage in New Orleans or was it the fact that the levees could not sustain the level of the water that was rising and thus broke. This essay shed light to the ugliness that most Americans are not aware and if not, they are fully aware of it and only decides to turn the other cheek and pretend its non-existent chooses to ignore it. Hurricane Katrina did not only destroy homes, businesses schools, hospitalsRead MoreA New System Of The State Of Texas1145 Words   |  5 Pageshurricane almost wiped out the whole city. On September 8th, 1900, a potent hurricane producing wind up to 120 miles per hour and flooded the city with about 15 feet of water made landfall. The aftermath of the hurricane was horrific, it broke the city down to rubbl es and a few thousands of people lost their lives. The city had a choice of either being wiped off the map from the hurricane’s damage or to start the rebuild process as soon as possible. Galveston chose to unite as one and wasted zero timeRead More Hurricane Katrina: A Man-made Disaster Essay1364 Words   |  6 PagesAt 7:10 EDT on August 29, 2005 Hurricane Katrina made landfall, etching lasting memories of those living in and around the New Orleans, Louisiana. It was this day that Hurricane Katrina came ashore and caused what was to be thought as one of the â€Å"most destructive storm in terms of economic losses† (Hurricane Katrina —, 2007) of all times. Who was to be blamed for the failure in emergence management response and preparation, no one seemed to know or understand. Those left in the wake of thisRead MoreThe No-Fear Legacy Essay1697 Words   |  7 PagesThe No-Fear Legacy ~Nicole and Dawn~ It all started on August 23, 2005. It seemed like it was just going to be another average day. Nicole had stayed the night at Dawn’s and now they were both walking down to the bus stop for school. Nicole’s blonde hair blew in the wind while her pink earrings clanked like a wind chime. They stepped on to the bus and prepared for the long ride. Nicole and Dawn started noticing clouds moving in from the ocean. They were moving faster and faster. Every secondRead MoreGovernment Response Of Hurricane Katrina1194 Words   |  5 PagesGovernment Response to Hurricane Katrina Levels of Government In my opinion, all three levels of government failed the people of New Orleans in responding to Hurricane Katrina. There was plenty of pushing the blame on one another that ended up delaying responses and finding results. It seemed like one level of government would try saying the other level of government is responsible for that role. For example, The Director of FEMA, Michael Brown would say that the local and state are in charge ofRead MoreRebuilding After Hurracane Katrina Essay927 Words   |  4 PagesOn August 29, 2005, Hurricane Katrina brought a death toll in the thousands and millions of dollars in damage. It was a severe storm â€Å"with winds in excess of 150 miles per hour [that] caused 20-foot-high waves to pound the coastlines of Alabama, Florida, Louisiana, and Mississippi† (Dass-Brailsford 24). Other than the rescue missions, the city was also concerned with clean up efforts and restoring basic service to residents, which was a huge challenge to the city gover nment. On the other hand, differentRead MoreThe Mitigation Measures Necessary For Emergency Relief Measures1698 Words   |  7 Pagesmeasures had been utilized. The mitigation measures necessary to prevent this disaster would have been a fraction of the cost spent on emergency relief measures. For many people in New Orleans this scenario was a reality when Hurricane Katrina happened. Hurricane Katrina caused one hundred and thirty five billon dollars in damage and the death of at least nine hundred and eighty six lives (Plyer, 2014). The city lost all government control and the city fell victim to anarchy. There was little foodRead MoreThe Storm Of The Hurricane Katrina1193 Words   |  5 Pages2005 the Hurricane Katrina had stuck. â€Å"When the storm made landfall, it had a Category 3 rating on the Saffir-Simpson Hurricane Scale–it brought sustained winds of 100–140 miles per hour–and stretched some 400 miles across.†(Hurricane Katrina.†) K atrina had destroyed the state, Louisianan is located below the city level. A known target to be floored by the Gulf Coast. â€Å"Local, state and federal -- was unprepared, uncoordinated and overwhelmed in dealing with the Hurricane Katrina disaster that devastated